Leaders Create Environments, Not Answers
The Shift from Command to Architecture Your job is not to have answers. Your job is to create conditions where answers emerge.
In my early days as CEO, I thought leadership meant having answers. The team would have questions and I was expected to respond. So I worked hard to stay ahead of them. I anticipated questions. I gathered insights from mentors and experts to supplement my own limited knowledge.
This somewhat worked. Then a crisis arrived that no preparation could have addressed, and I learned what leadership actually requires.
The Crisis
My third cofounder was hit by a car and sent to the ICU on life support. He was declared brain dead moments before I was notified. Each time I recount this, my body remembers the vertigo of understanding the world had just changed.
He was not only our cofounder but our CTO, responsible for our entire tech stack. The accident occurred two days before I was supposed to start raising our next round of financing. I knew the team would be distraught. I knew observers would predict we were sinking.
When I presented the situation to one of my most trusted mentors, he said: "I don't have answers. Just do the best you can." There was no playbook. This was my first experience with real leadership.
The Shift
In tense situations, asymmetric information causes damage. So the first thing I committed to was full transparency. I shared the news with the team and invited them to join me at the ICU. I emailed all investors immediately and committed to keeping them informed.
After visiting the ICU, everyone was devastated. Questions started coming. What are we going to do for him? What about his family? What does this mean for the company? Are we supposed to come to the office and work?
My mentor's words echoed: do the best you can. But I didn't have answers. Pretending to have them in hopes of creating false comfort would backfire. I asked myself what I could actually do. The answer came immediately: create the support to find the answers.
The Four Elements of an Environment
Creating an environment where answers can emerge requires four things:
- Information: reduce asymmetry fast. I committed to full transparency with the team and our investors. No one was left wondering what was happening. When people don't have information, they fill the gap with fear.
- Resources: bring in expertise. I brought in a grief counselor to help us process what was happening. Having an external professional lead emotional guidance neutralized power dynamics. I offered to pay for any therapy or support people needed.
- Decision rights: push choices to the edges. When the question of work call up, I didn't answer it. I put it back to the team. Everyone was empowered to make that decision for themselves.
- Norms: set the tone. I explained that our office was no longer a place to do work but a place dedicated to helping everyone process. This set the tone. Almost immediately, people shifted from fear to action.
Beyond Crisis
Crisis forced me to learn this. But the insight applies to everyday leadership. When an employee asks you how to solve a problem, your first instinct might be to answer. Resist it. Ask: "What do you recommend?" Then wait.
The pattern is the same in every case. Your job is not to solve. Your job is to create the conditions for solving. Information. Resources. Decision rights. Norms. Get those right, and answers emerge from the people closest to the problem.
The Bottom Line: Your job isn't to have all the answers. It's to create conditions where answers emerge. That's what real leadership is.
Brendan Marshall
Back to beta